Get access to everything we publish when you sign up for Outside+.
There’s just something about cheese. Few of us can resist the rich creaminess of a good Brie, the comforting gooeyness of melted mozzarella, or the sassy bite of aged cheddar. Cheese adds savory notes, volumes of flavor, and a hard-to-beat charisma to any recipe.
But when it comes to our health, cheese is nothing to smile about. It’s high in saturated fats and compounds that can promote inflammation and increase risk of heart disease. Cheese also contains lactose, a type of sugar that’s difficult to digest, and it’s linked with food sensitivities in many people.
Conventionally raised dairy also contains harmful antibiotics and added hormones. And even organic dairy naturally contains hormones that can accelerate growth and development in children, including early puberty, and may spur the growth of certain tumors and increase the risk of breast, colorectal, and prostate cancers. In one recent study, for example, women who consumed the most dairy products were more likely to die over a 12-year period, compared with those who consumed the least.
While there are a growing number of great cheese alternatives (Daiya, anyone?), true cheese lovers agree that some dairy-free cheeses can be rubbery and bland. Some also contain soy, another allergen, and most are made with casein, a milk product that’s not appropriate for anyone who follows a vegan diet or is seriously allergic to milk products.
For the best-tasting, cleanest, dairy-free cheese, try making your own. You can find lots of dairy-free and vegan cookbooks with cheese recipes, or experiment with your own. Some tips to get you started:
1. Make Vegan Cheeses with Nuts
Begin with nuts as the main ingredient—they’re high in protein and healthy fats that add body and a creamy mouth-feel. Soak nuts for 3-8 hours to improve their texture and reduce compounds that interfere with digestion and protein absorption. Pine nuts, cashews, or walnuts are the best choices for soft cheeses, while macadamias, almonds, and Brazil nuts make great bases for firmer cheeses.
2. Use Coconut Oil
Try adding coconut oil for texture. Though it’s a saturated fat, most studies show that it actually improves cholesterol levels.
3. Add Nut Butters
Add cashew or other nut butters for extra creaminess.They are especially useful for making short-cut cheese sauces.
4. Go With a Good Blender
Use a high-quality, powerful blender or food processor to purée ingredients until they’re very smooth and creamy. This may take several minutes in some food processors—if so, be sure to turn the processor off every 30-45 seconds to avoid overheating.
5. Incorporate Nutritional Yeast
Add seasonings. Nutritional yeast adds a tangy, cheese-like flavor, and miso provides depth, earthiness, and “umami” flavor (the savory element in cheese). Flavored salts, herbs, and spices are other good additions.
6. Try Fermenting Your Vegan Cheese
Fermenting your cheese to creates flavor depth and encourages the growth of beneficial lactic acid bacteria. For traditional fermenting, start with rejuvelac-a fermented beverage made from wheat berries—or take a shortcut with probiotic powders or capsules.